From the lesson · Cria · B2
How do you say “It does not seem fair to us” in Portuguese?
The answer
Não nos parece justo… / A gente não acha justo…
It does not seem fair to us… / We don't think it's fair…
Example from the lesson
‘Não nos parece justo afirmar que a Vila foi vendida.’ — Isso: depois do ‘não’, o ‘nos’ vem antes. Falando: ‘A gente não acha justo…’
‘It does not seem fair to us to claim that the Vila has been sold.’ — That's it: after ‘não’, the ‘nos’ comes first. Out loud: ‘We don't think it's fair…’
In real life
Formal rule 2: some words pull the pronoun in front of the verb: não, nunca, já, também, que, quem, onde, se, quando. ‘Não parece-nos’ ✗ is the classic overcorrection.
The rule, explained
A public reply is written Portuguese at its most formal, and Ray keeps translating it back into speech. Written: ‘Agradecemos-lhe a atenção’, ‘Não nos parece justo’, ‘Os dados que nos foram pedidos seguem anexos’, ‘Convidamo-la a visitar a Fervo’. Spoken: ‘Obrigada por falar da gente’, ‘A gente não acha justo’, ‘Me manda até amanhã?’. Knowing both, and when to use which, is a B2 skill.
The secret: in English the object pronoun always sits after the verb (‘we thank you’, ‘it seems to us’), so English speakers either copy speech into formal writing (‘Lhe agradecemos’ ✗ at the start of a formal letter) or put hyphens everywhere (‘Não parece-nos’ ✗). Formal written Portuguese has two simple rules. One: never start a sentence with an unstressed pronoun, so attach it after the verb with a hyphen (‘Agradecemos-lhe’, ‘Convidamo-la’). Two: words like não, nunca, já, que, quem, se and quando pull the pronoun in front of the verb (‘Não nos parece’, ‘que nos foram pedidos’). In speech, forget both: the pronoun goes before the verb (‘Me manda’).
Module checkpoint: you set conditions with ‘desde que’, argued with nouns, reported a whole column and wrote a formal reply. And a false friend for formal praise: ‘notório’ means well-known, usually in a good or neutral way. English ‘notorious’ is ‘de má fama’.
Grammar notes
- Formal start: verb-pronoun with hyphen: Agradecemos-lhe · Convidamo-la (convidamos + a) · Envio-lhe.
- Pulled forward by não, nunca, já, que, quem, se, quando: Não nos parece · que nos foram pedidos.
- Speech: pronoun before the verb, even at the start: Me manda · Te agradeço · A gente te convida.
Where it shows up
In the lesson “Não nos parece justo” of the Portuguese course (Cria · B2). Scene, exercise and a voice to repeat after.
From the same lesson
- agradecemos-lhe a atenção / obrigada por falar da gente· we thank you for your attention
- Os dados que nos foram pedidos seguem anexos.· The data requested from us are attached
- Convidamo-la a visitar a Fervo· We invite you to visit the Fervo
- O notório trabalho da Fervo / notório é muito conhecido· The Fervo's well-known work
- Me manda até amanhã? / vem pra Vila!· Can you send it to me by tomorrow?
