From the lesson · Bigode · C1
How do you say “glorifies crime” in Portuguese?
The answer
faz apologia ao crime / Apologia aqui é defender, elogiar
glorifies crime / ‘apologia’ here means defending, praising
Example from the lesson
Tem gente que ainda diz que o funk faz apologia ao crime.
Some people still say funk glorifies crime.
In real life
False friend: ‘apologia’ is a defence or glorification (from the Greek ‘apologia’, a speech in defence). An apology is ‘um pedido de desculpas’. The accusation that funk ‘faz apologia’ is an old debate in Brazil; here Inês calls it prejudice.
The rule, explained
A Brazilian panel is a dance: give a little ground, then take your point. ‘Concordo em parte, mas…’, ‘Por mais que eu respeite…’, ‘Ainda que…’. Nobody wins by flattening the others, and conceding (‘dar o braço a torcer’) counts in your favour.
The secret: English concedes with the indicative: ‘however much the periphery produces’, ‘even if the audience comes’. Fluent English speakers keep that indicative in Portuguese (‘por mais que a quebrada produz’ ✗, ‘ainda que o público vem’ ✗), and it's one of the clearest give-aways at C1. Concessive connectors pull the subjunctive: ‘por mais que a quebrada produza’, ‘ainda que o público venha’. And to reframe, English says ‘it's not about X, it's about Y’; the calque ‘não é sobre X’ is spreading online, but in a debate the native move is ‘Não se trata de X, e sim de Y’.
And a false friend that can derail a debate: ‘apologia’ is a defence or a glorification (‘fazer apologia ao crime’), never an apology (‘um pedido de desculpas’). Priya almost thanked the funk for saying sorry.
Grammar notes
- Subjunctive after: por mais que · ainda que · mesmo que · embora · nem que (‘nem que eu tenha que…’ = even if I have to…).
- Tratar-se de is impersonal: ‘Trata-se de um problema antigo’, ‘Não se trata de dinheiro’. No subject before it.
- Conceding: concordo em parte · tem razão nesse ponto · dou o braço a torcer. Countering: mas · no entanto · por outro lado · ainda assim.
Where it shows up
In the lesson “Por mais que digam” of the Portuguese course (Bigode · C1). Scene, exercise and a voice to repeat after.
From the same lesson
- O tema da mesa é… / Posso entrar nesse ponto?· the topic of the panel is
- Por mais que a quebrada produza muito· however much the ‘quebrada’ produces
- Concordo em parte, mas eu discordo… / dar o braço a torcer· I partly agree, but I disagree
- Não se trata de levar…, e sim de trazer…· it's not about taking…, but about bringing
- ainda que o público venha· even if the audience comes
