Skip to content
All the words in Portuguese

From the lesson · Pegando o jeito · A2

How do you say “Have you talked to…? — Yes, I have” in Portuguese?

The answer

Você já falou com…? — Já!

Have you (already) talked to…? — Yes, I have!

Register: neutral

Example from the lesson

E aí, você já falou com os fornecedores? — Já!

So, have you talked to the suppliers yet? — Yes, I have!

In real life

English asks with the present perfect (‘Have you talked…?’); Portuguese asks with the simple past + ‘já’. The short answer is just ‘Já!’ (yes, already). The short ‘no’ is ‘Ainda não’ (not yet).

The rule, explained

The pretérito perfeito is the tense for finished actions: yesterday, last night, this morning, five minutes ago. Regular verbs follow three patterns. For ‘eu’: -ar → -ei (liguei, mandei), -er → -i (respondi), -ir → -i (pedi, abri). For ‘ele/ela/você’: -ou, -eu, -iu (mandou, respondeu, pediu).

The secret: English loves the present perfect (‘I've called’, ‘Have you spoken to him?’, ‘He hasn't answered yet’). Portuguese uses the simple past for all of that: ‘Já liguei’, ‘Você já falou com ele?’, ‘Ele não respondeu ainda’. ‘Tenho ligado’ exists, but it means something repeated up to now (‘I've been calling every day’). For one finished action, even this morning, it's ‘liguei’.

‘Já’ does the job of ‘already’ and ‘yet’ in questions: ‘Você já abriu o e-mail?’. Answer ‘Já!’ or ‘Ainda não’. And ‘ainda’ can go at the end: ‘Ele não respondeu ainda’ = ‘Ele ainda não respondeu’, both natural.

Grammar notes

  • -ar: eu liguei, você/ele/ela mandou, a gente fechou, vocês/eles mandaram. Spelling: ligar → liguei (the u keeps the hard g), ficar → fiquei.
  • -er / -ir: eu respondi, pedi, abri; ele respondeu, pediu, abriu; eles responderam, pediram, abriram.
  • ‘ter + particípio’ (tenho ligado, tenho trabalhado) = something repeated from the past up to now: ‘Tenho trabalhado muito’ (I've been working a lot lately). Not for one action.

Where it shows up

In the lesson “Já liguei pro fornecedor!” of the Portuguese course (Pegando o jeito · A2). Scene, exercise and a voice to repeat after.

Open the free lesson

From the same lesson