From the lesson · Bigode · C1
How do you say “pronoun before the verb” in Portuguese?
The answer
Pronome antes do verbo / frase não começa com pronome
pronoun before the verb / a sentence doesn't start with a pronoun
Example from the lesson
Na fala, o pronome vem antes. Na escrita formal, frase não começa com pronome.
In speech, the pronoun comes first. In formal writing, a sentence doesn't start with a pronoun.
In real life
The whole system in two lines. Spoken Brazilian: ‘me’, ‘te’, ‘se’ before the verb almost always. Formal writing: not at the start of a sentence (‘Lembro-me’), but before the verb after an attractor (‘que me…’, ‘não me…’).
The rule, explained
A letter meant to be read aloud at a festival can afford to be literary. Priya's has three registers in it: the literary ‘escrevo-te’, the neutral ‘que me ensinaram’, and the spoken ‘Me lembro’ she uses with Ray. Knowing which pronoun order belongs where is one of the clearest signs of C1 Portuguese.
The secret: English has one order (‘I remember’, ‘who taught me’), so English speakers guess, and often guess the European way: pronoun after the verb everywhere (‘que ensinaram-me’ ✗, ‘nunca deixou-me’ ✗) because it looks ‘more correct’. Brazilian Portuguese works with three rules. One: in speech, the pronoun goes before the verb (‘Me lembro’, ‘Te escrevo’). Two: in formal writing, a sentence doesn't start with a pronoun (‘Lembro-me’, ‘Escrevo-te’). Three, valid in every register: attractor words (que, não, nunca, ninguém, já, quem) pull the pronoun before the verb: ‘que me ensinaram’, ‘nunca me deixou’, ‘ninguém me chama’. Master rule three and you'll never write ‘que ensinaram-me’ again.
And a half false friend from Priya's first day: ‘decorar’ means to decorate, and also to learn by heart. ‘Eu tinha decorado uma frase’ = I had memorised a sentence. No ribbons involved.
Grammar notes
- Attractors (pronoun before the verb in any register): não, nunca, ninguém, nada, que, quem, onde, já, sempre, talvez, também, and conditional ‘se’ (‘se me pedirem…’).
- Start of a formal sentence: verb-hyphen-pronoun: Lembro-me · Escrevo-te · Sabe-se · Envio-lhe. In speech: Me lembro · Te escrevo · Se sabe.
- With the future and conditional, formal writing uses mesóclise (‘levar-te-ei’, ‘dir-se-ia’): you'll read it in old books and legal texts; in a letter today, ‘vou te levar’ or ‘levo-te’ is enough.
Where it shows up
In the lesson “Escrevo-te de uma laje” of the Portuguese course (Bigode · C1). Scene, exercise and a voice to repeat after.
From the same lesson
- Lê pra mim / Parece carta de livro· read it to me
- escrevo-te / levo-te um pouco daqui· I write to you
- ninguém me chama de gringa / que me ensinaram / nunca me deixou· nobody calls me gringa
- Lembro-me do primeiro dia / Me lembro· I remember the first day
- eu tinha decorado uma frase / decorar é memorizar· I had memorised a sentence
