From the lesson · Desenrolado · B1
How do you say “That's where I discovered” in Portuguese?
The answer
Foi lá que eu descobri…
That's where I discovered…
Example from the lesson
Era uma biblioteca. Foi lá que eu descobri a música do Brasil.
It was a library. That's where I discovered Brazilian music.
In real life
‘Foi + place/time + que’ highlights the key moment: ‘Foi lá que…’ (that's where), ‘Foi em 2019 que…’ (it was in 2019 that). ‘Descobri’ (perfeito): an event, it happened once.
The rule, explained
A good story has a stage, events and a backstory. Portuguese gives each one its own past: the imperfeito sets the stage (‘Quando eu era criança’, ‘eu tinha doze anos’, ‘eu trabalhava num festival’), the perfeito moves the story (‘descobri’, ‘ouvi’, ‘liguei’, ‘cheguei’), and the mais-que-perfeito goes back before the moment you're telling (‘ele nunca tinha saído do Brasil’, ‘eu só tinha estudado num aplicativo’).
The secret: English can tell a whole life in the simple past: ‘I was a child, I loved the library, I discovered music, I worked at a festival, I heard a song.’ English speakers translate every one of those with the perfeito and the story goes flat (‘Eu fui criança’ ✗, ‘Eu trabalhei num festival quando ouvi’ means you did a job and then heard something). Ask each verb: is it scenery (imperfeito), an event (perfeito), or something that had already happened (tinha + participle)? And when you reach the turning point, mark it: ‘Foi lá que…’, ‘Foi aí que eu entendi’.
And a false friend from Priya's childhood: ‘livraria’ is a bookshop. A library is ‘biblioteca’. In the Vila, as Yuri says, the library is where the book is free.
Grammar notes
- Imperfeito: background, age, habits, what was going on: era, tinha, adorava, trabalhava, errava.
- Perfeito: events, one-off actions: descobri, ouvi, liguei, cheguei, disse. Mais-que-perfeito: before the event: tinha saído, tinha estudado.
- Turning points: ‘Foi lá que…’, ‘Foi aí que…’, ‘Foi quando…’. Future ‘while’: ‘enquanto eu estiver’.
Where it shows up
In the lesson “Foi aí que eu entendi” of the Portuguese course (Desenrolado · B1). Scene, exercise and a voice to repeat after.
From the same lesson
- Quando eu era criança… / Eu tinha doze anos.· When I was a child
- livraria (× biblioteca)· bookshop
- eu trabalhava num festival em Londres quando ouvi…· I was working at a festival in London when I heard
- nunca tinha saído do Brasil / eu só tinha estudado num aplicativo· had never left Brazil
- Foi aí que eu entendi / valeu a pena· That's when I understood
