From the lesson · Desenrolado · B1
How do you say “What if you stayed…?” in Portuguese?
The answer
E se você ficasse…? / se eu ficasse…
What if you stayed…? / if I stayed…
Example from the lesson
E se você ficasse mais um ano na Fervo? — Se eu ficasse, a minha mãe ia me matar!
What if you stayed another year at Fervo? — If I stayed, my mum would kill me!
In real life
‘E se’ + imperfect subjunctive = a soft, ‘just imagine’ proposal. It's how Brazilians float an idea without pressure. ‘Ia me matar’ = would kill me (spoken ‘would’, lesson 12).
The rule, explained
Big offers come with two kinds of ‘if’. The imagined one: ‘E se você ficasse mais um ano?’ (what if you stayed?) is a gentle way to float an idea. The real one: ‘Se você ficar, a gente faz o Travessia de novo’ (if you stay, we'll do it again) puts a plan on the table. Ray uses both, in that order, on purpose.
The secret: English already has this split, ‘if you stay’ × ‘if you stayed’, but English speakers don't hear it as a choice, so in Portuguese they mix the halves: ‘Se você fica, a gente faria’ ✗, ‘Se você ficasse, a gente faz’ ✗. Keep each pair together. Real possibility: ‘se’ + future subjunctive (ficar, puder, quiser) + present or ‘vai’ (‘a gente faz’, ‘você vai ser’). Imagined: ‘se’ + imperfect subjunctive (ficasse, pudesse, quisesse) + conditional or spoken imperfect (‘seria’, ‘ia me matar’, ‘eu respondia’). Switching from one to the other is how you show how serious you are.
And a false friend for a big decision: ‘sensível’ = sensitive (Priya cried at the opening). Sensible is ‘sensato’, or ‘ter juízo / bom senso’. ‘Seja sensata!’ is what every mother says when her daughter wants to stay abroad.
Grammar notes
- Real: se + future subjunctive → present / vai + infinitive: ‘Se você ficar, a gente faz.’
- Imagined: se + imperfect subjunctive → conditional / spoken imperfect: ‘Se você ficasse, a gente faria / fazia.’
- ‘E se…?’ + imperfect subjunctive = a gentle suggestion: ‘E se a gente fosse amanhã?’
Where it shows up
In the lesson “E se você ficasse?” of the Portuguese course (Desenrolado · B1). Scene, exercise and a voice to repeat after.
From the same lesson
- Posso te fazer uma proposta?· Can I make you an offer
- se você ficar, a gente faz… / sócia· if you stay, we'll do
- Pensa com calma. / Se eu pudesse, eu respondia agora.· Take your time
- a papelada a gente vê depois, com quem entende· we'll sort out the paperwork later, with someone who knows
- Seja sensata! / sensível· Be sensible
