From the lesson · Desenrolado · B1
How do you say “as if he were” in Portuguese?
The answer
como se fosse o dono
as if he were / was the owner
Example from the lesson
O senhor tá falando como se fosse o dono do festival!
You're talking as if you were the owner of the festival!
In real life
‘Como se’ (as if) always takes the imperfect subjunctive, even about now: ‘como se fosse’, never ‘como se é’ or ‘como se era’.
The rule, explained
The neighbours compare, imagine and promise: ‘como se fosse o dono’, ‘se o palco fosse do outro lado…’, ‘se tiver festival…’. Today's new piece is ‘como se’ (as if): Seu Toninho talks as if he owned the festival; Dona Zuleide danced as if she were twenty.
The secret: English says ‘as if he WAS/WERE the owner’, ‘as if she WAS twenty’, so English speakers reach for the past indicative: ‘como se era o dono’ ✗, or the present, ‘como se é’ ✗. ‘Como se’ always takes the imperfect subjunctive, whatever the time: ‘como se fosse’, ‘como se tivesse’, ‘como se soubesse’. It's the same form as ‘se eu fosse’ from lesson 9, so you already know it. And notice the spoken shortcut: in the ‘would’ half, people in São Paulo often use the imperfect: ‘eu colocava’ (= colocaria), ‘o som ia’ (= iria), ‘ninguém aguentava’ (= aguentaria). Use it when talking; write the ‘-ia’ form.
Module checkpoint: the week after the festival. Hypotheses with ‘se’ + fosse/tivesse + -ia (lesson 9), contrasts with ‘embora’, ‘apesar de’, ‘mesmo que’ and ‘porém’ (lesson 10), formal × spoken pronouns (lesson 11), and three false friends: êxito, prejuízo, resumir.
Grammar notes
- ‘Como se’ + imperfect subjunctive: como se fosse · como se tivesse · como se soubesse · como se morasse.
- Spoken ‘would’: the imperfect (colocava, ia, aguentava). Written: the conditional (colocaria, iria, aguentaria).
- Real future ‘se tiver’ × imagined ‘se tivesse’: ‘Se tiver festival, a gente faz.’ × ‘Se tivesse festival todo mês, eu ia em todos.’
Where it shows up
In the lesson “Como se fosse o dono da praça” of the Portuguese course (Desenrolado · B1). Scene, exercise and a voice to repeat after.
From the same lesson
- por conta da casa· on the house
- ninguém aguentava / como se tivesse vinte anos· nobody would have lasted
- alto demais / Parecia que…· far too loud
- Se o palco fosse do outro lado, o som ia pra rua de trás.· If the stage were on the other side, the sound would go to the back street
- Mesmo que o som seja alto… me avisa antes!· Even if the sound is loud… let me know first
